Martin Samuel: Commentary
Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000
According to the Encyclopaedia Britannica, Hallowe’en is traditionally believed to provide the most favourable opportunity in the calendar for divinations concerning marriage, luck and prosperity and is, indeed, the only day when the help of the gentleman downstairs can be invoked for such a purpose. So it is perhaps fitting that tonight, October 31, a venture with more than a whiff of sulphur around its configuration will be placed before the public at White Hart Lane.
The marriage of Tottenham Hotspur and Juande Ramos is, if not unholy, certainly unwholesome, containing as it does a witches brew of betrayal, skulduggery, deceit and double-talk. A fresh seasoning was added to the pot yesterday, that of gutlessness, with Daniel Levy, the chairman, strikingly absent as Ramos, his new manager, and his two assistants, Gustavo Poyet (technical coach) and Marcos Álvarez (fitness coach), were unveiled on the eve of a Carling Cup fourth-round tie with Blackpool. Ramos’s first win should come easily, as should several more, looking at Tottenham’s November fixture list.
After the “mighty Seasiders”, twentieth in what used to be called the second division, is a visit to troubled Middlesbrough in the Barclays Premier League, a Uefa Cup tie away to Hapoel Tel-Aviv (eleventh of 12 in Israel’s Ligat Ha’Al), a league fixture at home to struggling Wigan Athletic and another away at mid-table mediocrities West Ham United. That takes Tottenham to November 25 and on the next day, we are informed, Levy will speak at an extraordinary meeting of shareholders. Probably.
By contrast, the extraordinary element of yesterday’s proceedings was that Spurs thought the official line - Levy did not want to disrupt Ramos’s big day by talking – was going to be bought by anybody. So, in lieu of the man who calls the shots, Tottenham’s executive management was represented by Damien Comolli, the sporting director. As the club sit eighteenth in the league when an assault on Champions League qualification was their aim, his direction would appear to have a downward momentum, but whereas this sudden descent earned Martin Jol, the former manager, several months of humiliation and his ticket, Comolli sat proudly by Ramos’s side as if he was part of a vibrant new team, not a remnant of a failed, old one.
Asked what Comolli would have to do to warrant dismissal, he seemed momentarily flustered. “That is a good question, I have never thought about it,” he said. “I have things to do for the club and if Daniel and the board were not happy, they would ask me to leave. My job is 60 per cent about the future and 40 per cent about now.”
In other words, like all men in his position, there is nothing to go wrong for which Comolli can be held specifically responsible. If Ramos gets beaten tonight, he is instantly on the back foot, but Comolli? Judge me in ten years. Nice work if you can get it.
And more and more do get it. As Comolli pointed out, the Tottenham system is in place at 99 per cent of clubs around Europe. “Clubs that win trophies and football matches,” he said. “I am 100 per cent convinced it works and see no reason why it should not work in England.”
Yet the most consistently successful English clubs in the Premier League era have been founded on the vision of one man: the manager. Nobody directs football at Arsenal other than Arsène Wenger; nobody plays the transfer market on behalf of Sir Alex Ferguson at Manchester United. Chelsea could have created a third dynasty in that fashion through José Mourinho, but the owner would not leave well enough alone.
Tottenham, meanwhile, are on their eighth manager in the time in which Arsenal have had one and have in that period collected the League Cup (in 1999) against three Premier League titles and four FA Cups (including two Doubles). Tottenham’s ambition is to qualify for the Champions League. Arsenal have enjoyed an uninterrupted ten years in that tournament.
Quizzed on why he was not the new head coach, Comolli raised more questions than answers. “There is someone next to me who is very competent at what he does and has a proven record of winning things and winning in style,” he said. “How you get results matters. Juande gets results with style, so that is his job, not mine.”
And therefore raises the issue that if Ramos is so gilt-edged and innovative, why does he need a football director above him calling the shots? “The way it works is very simple,” Comolli explained. “Juande will say this is what we need, this is the characteristic of the player we look for and, as scouting staff, we come back with choices for him. If he has a specific name, fantastic, it saves me the job.”
What job? Managers know players. Managers know what they want. Why would any manager relinquish control of such an important part of his role and does that not provide built-in conflict? Comolli claims that Jol was the driving force behind all signings. It is fair to say that statement would not remain unchallenged in certain company.
Nor would the version of events forwarded by Ramos that he was not offered a position at White Hart Lane long before Jol’s dismissal last week. Ignoring photographic evidence of Tottenham executives in Spain as early as August, plus reports that at an official press conference at Seville, he spoke of receiving an offer from the club, Ramos said: “There were some pictures in Seville, but I did not meet any of the Tottenham directors. I said I had three or four offers from other clubs, that is all.”
Still in danger of being reported to Uefa by José MarÍa Del Nido, the Seville president, for making an illegal approach to Ramos, Tottenham were nervous on this issue, and Donna Cullen, the director of communications, jumped in whenever talk strayed to the establishment of a timeline between first approach and appointment. Not that there is anything to hide.
As for Ramos, he was putting his faith in an England long since passed. Asked if he was worried that his employers would one day be meeting his successor behind his back, he appeared unfazed. “British football has a reputation of being very clean,” he said. “So I will put all my trust in the fair play of British football.” At which point, the music from The Omen could be heard. Only joking, Damien.
Lost in translation
Five other managers with poor English when they arrived
Attilio Lombardo (Crystal Palace, 1998) The Italian player-manager gave his first team talk via an interpreter and Palace were 3-0 down to Aston Villa within 35 minutes. “The players failed to put into practice what I had told them – maybe it was the language problem,” he said.
Claudio Ranieri (Chelsea, 2000-2004) The Italian shied away from press conferences for months and was just about able to say “tinkerman” when his four-year stint ended.
Jean Tigana (Fulham, 2000-2003) John Collins, Fulham’s French-speaking midfield player, translated for the toothpick-chewing Tigana at first, but the manager quickly learnt English.
Jacques Santini (Tottenham Hotspur, 2004) It sometimes took several minutes to realise that Santini was speaking English rather than French and it took him only 13 games to decide to head back to France.
Alain Perrin (Portsmouth, 2005) The Frenchman was widely criticised during his brief spell in charge and the language barrier meant that he was unable to hit back strongly in English.
Words: Bill Edgar

Martin Samuel, a seven times winner of Sports Writer of the Year, is the most successful sports journalist of his generation. The Times Chief Football Correspondent was named Sports Journalist of the Year at the 2008 British Press Awards, just weeks after retaining Sports Writer of the Year for the third time in succession at the Sports Journalists' Association awards for 2007. Judges described his work as "the highest form of journalism" and praised his "trenchant, fearless views, combined with wit and irony and the memorably killer phrase". Samuel scooped the What the Papers Say award in 2002, 2005 and 2006
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip

Find tickets for:
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
Special Offers now available
New Year in the USA!
.
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Martin Samuel is a thought provoking journalist and usually clearsighted but I suspect with all the pressure to produce more articles for 'On the Game 'he is beginning to become like the Premiership player who has played too many matches in a short period of time.
What was the board of Tottenham supposed to do. Martin Jol had lost the plot defensively.The deficiencies were less of a problem when more goals were being scored than let in last season. This season 'the chickens have come home to roost ' and Jol had not a clue how to resolve the problems. He had to go! Whether Ramos can turn things around remains to be seen. As for Comolli Martin Samuel may have a point though. It looks like he is going to have to 'produce some substantially better mid fielders and defenders from somewhere!
Graham Duncan, Austin, Texas USA
The supposed love in between Arsenal and the media is all of two months old. Ask AFC fans how tough it was reading negative press for months preceding that with all the Wenger going, Henry going, who else is going and you cant win anything with kids stories doing the rounds. Suffice it to say that at the first sign of weakness (the first defeat or loss in a cup tournament) a section of the media will be all over AFC.
Having said that, intense media focus and speculation is par for the course for a big club (or former big club). Chelsea of all clubs cant complain. The club didnt come out all smelling of roses after the Mourinho episode and the brief loss of form after that. The media focus stopped once CFC started winning again and will start if they fail to wrest back the premiership from Man U. And Ian, for all the Wenger bashing, what would your owner/ patron/ be all end all not give to have Wenger at the helm of his club.
Alex, Bangalore, India
The author has a right, nay, a duty, to express his anger at the way English football practices are being held up to ridicule by the malpractices of some Spurs executives. It's impossible to whitewash recent actions by Spurs' executive branch, and merely expedient but also myopic to say "it's business as usual." And for so-called fans who now want to sweep the entire episode under the rug by altering the well-documented facts of the case: ignore this bit of history and you'll be doomed to repeat it. The board will deem itself exonerated and may well repeat the procedure when convenient. A jesting Einstein once said: "When the facts don't fit the theory, change the facts." The board would like nothing better. Separate morality from business --admittedly an increasing trend-- and you'll end up with the Mob.
Jacob van Oosterom, Sarnia, Canada
Arsenal DID have a sporting director for all intents and purposes. His name was David Dein and Wenger nearly resigned after he quit. Wenger identified the players, Dein brought them in. It worked incredibly well.
Aaron, London,
Can anyone explain to me why Tottenham are so vicously hated in the media? We are constantly subjected to this kind of biased journalism and i wondered if there was a good reason for it.. It cant be the boards behavior this season as ive been reading this kind of trash as long as ive had access to the internet. Also i cant find a daily newspaper with a kind word so i have to read the Daily Sport for its quality articles...
matt, essex , england
You seem to think that managers dont have scouts constantly informing them of players around the world. i find it extremely narrow minded and absurd to think that people like Arsene Wenger, Mark Hughes & others were able to sign these 'great' players simply based on their own knowledge of players. The media seem to be in love with Martin Jol and seem to think he was overlooked on transfers. Maybe he did not get all the players he wanted, but all the players signed like Zokora, Assou-Ekooto, D.Bent etc all went into the first team indicating that he wasn't that unhappy with them. Finally Sir Bobbby Robson is just one of many managers who is a fan of having a Sporting Director.
Amar, London,
shock horror. spurs sack a manager after their worst start to a premier league season and employ another one. how machiavellian! martin samuel is easily shocked and offended, it seems. funny, he seemed to be far less concerned over west ham's deceit regarding the tevez affair. i wonder why that could be...
whoateallthepies, london, uk
what about Benetez, his English was rubbish when he first came, how about that ?????????????????????????????
richie, london,
Good to see the arsenal press room have switched their wittering from chelsea to spurs. Good as a chels fan that is. Unlucky spurs fans ... you ain't read nothing yet!
And not sure where it went wrong for Jol. He won as much as wenger last season.
Ian, Brisbane,
Hey Tony, is the comedy festival on again down there mate? I've got some air miles to use up.
Ian, Brisbane,
We will never forget the golden years. Spurs will return to being the greatest team on the planet.
Tony, Melbourne, Australia
true hammer spoken, is it a wee bit of sour grapes I wonder.,
Lynn, Camberley, Surrey
WHAT A LOAD OF RUBBISH lets wait and see i cant beleave i sat and red that lot..i was there on sunday and without jol already they look like they are playing again for each other jol was only installed as a manager by default ...and the managers you have quoted had a bad time but look at the teams they took over .peeople that just sit there typeing for negland without thinking is what helps alot of the stupid rumour mill that can and does hurt teams
Kris YID Silver, peterborough, cambs
Very funny/cynical....
What is it with hacks these days?
Constantly sniffing for fresh blood?
Step back and allow a business to be run without your involvement, when has big business ever been clean? The top leagues of football are stained with cheats and wrong doing the world over but then again so is every patriarchal industry.
Forget the golden years.
Noskaj, London,
Nice piece of cynical writing!
Mr, milton keynes,
The only unholy marriage is that of the media and Arsenal
name, n,
You speak as though Jol and Hughton had presided over a team of young hearts who were unfairly split apart due to a management structure that has never worked at all when that simply isnât the case. When will the creative journalism stop?
Ramos is going to prove you all wrong in steady fashion because he wonât delude himself about what is going on in front of him. Itâs alright to keep going on about how you love the club to enable the supporters to blindly follow your every misadventure in the Technical area with sympathy but it is another thing to call a spade a spade when a player hasnât played well for months and you need to make what might be an unpopular decision in some quarters of the dressing room. Ramos wonât flinch in regards to those kinds of decisions. In an era when even partial rotation is a necessity, Jol was unable to keep a 22-man squad in harmony and this goes back over a year now. 4 man midfields with 4 center mids, no consistency at the back with King, etc, etc, etc.
Jol fooled people like yourself and used Commolli as a patsy of his own in the end to throw the cent off his inability to win the big game or coach like he deserved a dynasty.
It is now the Dynasty begins if only because we now have someone who knows what heâs doing.
Sam mollison, Orlando, USA
Levy has shown hmself to be untrustorthy.If Ranos does not succeed,evyl forces wil be quick to secure his demise.I aggree,a match made in hell.If Spurs continue to spend money they are doing,the club could find itself bankrupt in a few years.Their is only one man who could be blamed for this..
Beach_bum, St.Georges, Bermuda
Right, the press have had their say on the whole sorry saga at White Hart Lane this season. Whether you or I like it or not, Juande Ramos is the new Spurs head coach and Martin Jol is not. Get over it, give the new man (men) a chance and let me and the rest of the Spurs supporters get on with supporting our team. Thank you Martin Jol for all you achieved during your tenure and good luck Juande Ramos in the future.
Brad Matthews, London, England