Jonathan Sacks
Over 900 restaurants nationwide. Find your nearest now
There are some even in this sceptical age who still believe that God is an old man with a long beard. His name is Charles Darwin, patron saint of scientific atheists.
Next year will be a double anniversary for followers of Darwin: the 200th anniversary of his birth and the 150th anniversary of On the Origin of Species. We will no doubt hear it asserted that Darwin dealt a death blow to religious belief.
That, it should be said, is quite untrue. What it dealt a death blow to was one very poor argument for the existence of God, namely the argument from design. This argument figures nowhere in the Hebrew Bible. It does not even belong to its world of thought. It belongs instead to the tradition of Ancient Greece and to the idea that the most important truths are those that can be proved.
In fact none of the most important truths can be proved: that right is sovereign over might, that it is better to be loved than feared, that every human being however poor or powerless is worthy of respect, that peace is nobler than war, forgiveness greater than revenge, and hope a higher virtue than resignation to blind fate. Lives have been lived and civilisations built in defiance of these truths, yet they remain true.
What might a religious believer say to Darwin’s heirs? The following thoughts are purely hypothetical, but he or she might say, first, that Darwin helped us to understand the “how” of God’s “Let there be”. The Creator created not just life but life that is in itself creative.
That may be the meaning of the otherwise untranslatable phrase in Genesis ii, 3, that on the seventh day God rested “from all His work that God had created la’asot”, which means literally “to do, act, make”. Jewish commentators understood this to mean that God implanted creativity into nature. God creates something from nothing. Nature creates something from something. Darwin brought new depth to this idea.
The believer might continue that Darwin helped us to understand one of the key ideas of the Bible: the kinship between humans and animals. The first humans were forbidden to kill animals for food. The covenant with Noah after the flood was made also, as Genesis ix states five times, “with every living creature”. The Bible forbids cruelty to animals. This is the polar opposite of the view of Descartes, that animals lack souls and therefore can be used as we will.
The believer might go on to say, as does Matt Ridley in his book Genome, that we now know, having deciphered the genetic code, that all life in its seemingly endless variety has a single source. In his words: “There was only one creation, one single event when life was born.” The miracle of monotheism is that unity up there creates diversity down here.
The believer might wonder, as does Lord Rees, president of the Royal Society, in his Just Six Numbers, at the extraordinary precision of the six mathematical constants that determine the shape of the Universe, such that if even one were fractionally different neither we nor the Universe would exist.
The believer might mention other mysteries, such as how did life evolve from non-life? How did sentience emerge? How was the uniquely human capacity for self-consciousness born? How did life evolve at such speed that even Francis Crick, co-discoverer of DNA, was forced to suggest that it came from Mars? And the ultimate ontological question: why is there something rather than nothing?
We might refer to the arguments that persuaded the philosopher Antony Flew, late in life, to abandon his atheism. She might cite the curious paradox, noted by Richard Dawkins, that selfish genes get together and produce selfless people. We might wonder at the fact that Homo sapiens is the only known life form in the Universe capable of asking “Why?” And we might add, in the spirit of Godel’s Theorem, that there are truths within the system that cannot be proved within the system.
We would then say: None of these is a proof. Each, rather, is a source of wonder. The Psalm does not say, “The heavens prove the existence of God”. It says, “The heavens declare the glory of God”. Darwin helped us to understand how the many emerged from one. The more we know about the intricacy and improbability of life, the more reason we have to wonder and give thanks.
Sir Jonathan Sacks is Chief Rabbi of the United Hebrew Congregations of the Commonwealth
The moment your toes touch the sand and your gaze meets water, you know you’re in the Bahamas
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2005 / 55
£59,500
Great car insurance deals online
Circa £60,000
The Army Benevolent Fund
London
£28k+ Basic + Commission
Drummond Selection
London
12-15 days a year, c £12K
Springboard
London
£Competitive
American Airlines
Heathrow, London
Great Investment, River Views
One and Two Bed Apartments
Wandsworth Town
Times Online Property Search will help you Find It
like nothing on Earth!
.
Must end 28 Feb 2009!
Save up to 25%
Amazing Far East Offers
Visit Malaysia from £755pp
Great travel insurance deals online
.
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
"...dealt a death blow to religious belief."
No one sensible is going to assert that. Religious belief is not based on reason and no amount of reasonable evidence will undermine it.
Tikhon Savrasov, london,
"...curious paradox...selfish genes...selfless people."
I'll get to that "paradox", once I tire of citing the other curious paradoxes like how I safely eat something made up of poisonous stuff like Sodium atoms and Chlorine atoms and the unbelievable paradox of colourless water producing rainbows.
Matthai, Kerala, India
Religious leaders fail to acknowledge we are part of the natural world, with no need for supernatural waffle.
iain rae, tunbridge wells, U.K.
Trouble is, those who claim the "existence" of god is "evident" must, by the same "logic", also believe in the existence of Satan, devils, angels, demons and various other supernatural, magical (un-)beings flying around us.
Could we have a debate about their existence as well?
alan, germany,
In the new Testament, Romans 1:19,
For what can be known about God is evident to them, because God made it evident to them.20Ever since the creation of the world, his invisible attributes of eternal power and divinity have been able to be understood and perceived in what he has made.
Dr.Van Nostrand, Dublin, Eire
Science's precision has elucidated these ancient arguments; strengthening already cogent philosophical reasons for God.
Words like: spinning and disingenuous smack of involuntary recourse to emotivism for those whose atheism compels them to deny the transcendent meaning their hearts recognise.
Nathan, Cambridge, UK
He is spinning like a Campbell! Anyone reading the Bible is left in no doubt that war is better than peace when the jews are threatened - and illegal war at that - atrocities, slavery, ethnic cleansing with only enough time in between to sacrifice animals and stone those who disobey their parents.
Konrad Higgins, Reading, UK
Does the cruel, everlasting struggle for survival that has taken place over the aeons really look like the product of a benevolent god? The cruel reality of life's evolution - where even our own species was once nearly driven to instiction - are incompatible with the idea of an all-loving god.
James Barwell, York,
How disingenuous. Take one ambiguous word and pretend the bible is consistent with evolution, ignoring the actual creation story with is contradicted by evolution. Talk about cruelty to animals, ignoring Leviticus and the flood. Talk about peace being nobler than war, ignoring Joshua and more.
Alun ap Rhisiart, Clynder, Scotland
Progress. At least one theologian recognizes the fallacy of the design argument, although his reasoning is faulty (it just isn't needed to explain evolution). The rest of the article is filled with arguments long since debunked and foundational premises that are entirely disputable.
Ben, San Diego, CA, USA
I wish we had a few voices as good and profound as this in the Church of England.
Wallis, Cleobury Mortimer,
"The heavens declare the glory of god"
How? Care to provide some backup?
John, Wadhurst, , UK
I'd have to say that this atheist did much like this read. This is one of the most lucid and well thought out arguments from the religious I've read in a while. Kudos to the Rabbi.
Unfortunately for the believers; it's still based on belief in an invisible man.
David, Birmingham, USA
"The first humans were forbidden to kill animals for food."
Is there some reason to believe there would even be a desire or thought to kill a non-human animal for food?
Chris W., Portland, USA
Why bother to set up a straw man at the beginning with "We will no doubt hear it asserted that Darwin dealt a death blow to religious belief."
I don't actually know any atheists who claim this.
I do know lots of theists who fear that this may be true.
Tony Konrath, Key West, FL, USA
A good example of religious belief destroying the ability for rational thought. Even as a child I saw through these arguments.
Thomas, Liverpool,