Melanie Reid
Over 900 restaurants nationwide. Find your nearest now
Of all the tough constituencies in the UK, Gordon Brown had to walk into this one. Tough in the political sense, but above all in the street-fighting sense. Glasgow East wears the weary, pinched look of someone who has nothing in life and expects even less. Here, life expectancy for men is said to be lower than it is on the Gaza Strip. Here, the law of the jungle, not Westminister, rules.
And here, on July 24, in a by-election that may enter the history books, Labour could face its nemesis; a fateful collision of hegemony and happenstance.
Glasgow East is a part of the world that defies exaggeration. Desultory buses head out from the city centre towards some of the worst areas of concentrated poverty in the Western world: Shettleston, Barlanark, Garthamlock, Easterhouse, Parkhead... communities that figure with monotonous regularity both on the charge sheet at Glasgow Sheriff Court and at the top of lists of the most socially deprived wards in Britain. They might as well be called Guantanamo. For many thousands of welfare prisoners on sink estates, marooned by bad housing, violence, addiction, unemployment, ill health and shattered relationships, there is little chance of escape. Even a trip to Barlinnie, Scotland's most notorious prison, keeps them within the constituency boundaries.
In pockets, the jobless rate is up to 50 per cent. Male life expectancy is 63, 14 years below the British average. Fifty per cent have no qualifications; only 7.6 per cent are graduates. The over-60s make up 20 per cent of the population, 46 per cent of the constituency is social housing. Shettleston has the highest percentage of residents on incapacity benefit in the UK.
When Iain Duncan Smith, formerly in the mould of a classic right-wing Tory, came to Easterhouse he underwent something of an epiphany, leading him to create his Centre for Social Justice think-tank.
But if the East End's misery could move Conservative hearts, why did it not work on the ruling Labour politicians? One of the first ironies presented by Glasgow East is that it is a classic Labour rotten borough. One of the most rotten of the rotten, in fact. For generations, its inhabitants have been treated as cannon fodder; their votes taken for granted, their poverty contained but largely untackled. Vote Labour? It's what they do, along with drinking, drug taking, bad diet and Irn-Bru. Why should politicians spend money on people who are going to vote for them anyway? Much better to invest it in marginal seats.
In election after election, Glasgow's poor automatically did what their parents had done, with 60 per cent or more of the vote consistently cast for Labour. Corresponding generations of Labour politicians, both local and national, used such loyalty to secure their positions but singularly failed to reward their people.
One could argue that Labour-controlled planners created the problem in the first place, creating the “deserts with windaes”, as Billy Connolly called them, in the 1960s and 1970s. It was Labour which consistently failed to recognise that these vast dormitories - sans shops, sans transport links, sans anything - were a social disaster. It has always struck me as hugely symbolic of Labour's attitude to Scotland's poor that its health policy has always been to offer methadone to heroin addicts - a cheap, semi-permanent form of control rather than expensive rehabilitation.
Only in the past decade have things changed. New Labour started to help Glasgow East after devolution. Jack McConnell, a former First Minister, is credited with the vision of the new Clyde Gateway, a regeneration scheme that began to head east bearing £1.5 billion of private investment and 10,000 new homes. At Glasgow council, under the diligent and perceptive leader Steven Purcell, in the past five years £70million has been invested in new schools and £50 million in housing and apprenticeships for the young.
Then came the winning of the 2014 Commonwealth Games, a Purcell coup that will be used to help to regenerate the East of the city, bringing affordable housing, parks and sports facilities.
As insiders assert, all this amounts to something. Labour has a really good story to tell in Glasgow East. But there is a note of fear in their voices. For there is now a viable alternative to Labour, ready to snatch the prize. The Scottish National Party is poised on July 24 to steal a Labour birthright from under Gordon Brown's nose.
All that investment, the winning of the Games - why, it was Alex Salmond that did it, wasn't it? All the signs are there that this may happen. On paper, Glasgow East may be the 25th safest constituency in the UK, to lose it would require a 22 per cent swing, but we do not live in politically normal times. The Phi100, an authoritative survey of political experts, predicted on Tuesday that the SNP would win it from Labour. Ladbrokes, too, is offering odds of 8-13 on for a SNP win.
If Labour loses Glasgow East, the fallout will be seismic, far bigger than Crewe & Nantwich, signalling the disintegration of the party's hegemony in Scotland and in the UK as a whole. If the SNP can capture this constituency, new Labour is almost certainly finished both sides of the Border. The roof will fall in on Gordon Brown's Government and the Prime Minister himself will be unlikely to survive.
The final irony, of course, lies within the boundaries of Glasgow East, where the massed poor have perhaps not so much shifted their allegiance from Labour as ceased to have any allegiance at all - other than to Celtic FC. Will their lives change, whoever wins the by-election? Doubtful. Very doubtful. Sitting on the slow bus back to the East End, surrounded by drunks and junkies, the constituents inhale the ever-persistent whiff of broken promises.

Melanie Reid reports and commentates for The Times from Scotland. Before joining the paper, she was an award-winning columnist and senior assistant editor at The Herald in Glasgow
The moment your toes touch the sand and your gaze meets water, you know you’re in the Bahamas
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2005 / 55
£59,500
Great car insurance deals online
Circa £60,000
The Army Benevolent Fund
London
£28k+ Basic + Commission
Drummond Selection
London
12-15 days a year, c £12K
Springboard
London
£Competitive
American Airlines
Heathrow, London
Great Investment, River Views
One and Two Bed Apartments
Wandsworth Town
Times Online Property Search will help you Find It
like nothing on Earth!
.
Must end 28 Feb 2009!
Save up to 25%
Amazing Far East Offers
Visit Malaysia from £755pp
Great travel insurance deals online
.
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Born in the east end, managed to escape thanks to good working class parents who never voted labour, always seeing through their lies and pointing them out to us, and a brilliant evangelical church who pointed youngsters to the One who can change their lives whilst living in the midst of poverty.
Grace, inverness,
Some years ago I read Gordon Brown and Robin Cooks 'Scotland: The Real Divide'. 20 years later I can't deceive myself that things are so much better. For 10 years we had a government in Scotland that did as it was told, in order to keep middle England happy. And so the Real Divide remains.
Gregor Addison, Glasgow, Scotland
Sounds just like Liverpool...I wish we had the SNP equivalent, an English MP who looks after the interests of the English and not the Labour party that is, they'd have my vote.
judy, Liverpool, England
Great article Melanie.
I always said Labour in Scotland were like Bonnie Prince Charlie, the last arrogant unfeeling Pretender to leech off us. They've got Scotland, but they don't even want Scotland; Scottish voters are just a stepping stone to self-advancement.
sunniva, Falkirk, UK
I have often wondered why people in such places vote New Labour.
Or is it that, because they voted New Labour, they live in such places?
I am sure that the SNP will try to help the people in the area if they vote SNP at the election.
Iain Stewart, Barcelona, Spain
Fine piece about my home parish.
I was SNP organiser in 1987 General Election.
Labour deserve to be booted out.
phil macgiollabhain, letterkenny, donegal
Melanie, you'll probably like to know that this article is doing the rounds among bloggers in Scotland faster than a wildfire.
We all agree in removing our collective hat to you. Thanks.
Vincent McDee, Aberdeen, Scotland
Great article: an addition at the end on allegiance would have made it perfect
Labour in SW Scotland have had one great success, that is in conning the poor on both sides of the sectarian divide that they are devine.
Bryan, Isle of Skye, Scotland
'The Scottish National Party is poised on July 24 to steal a Labour birthright from under Gordon Brown's nose. '
Why is it a Labour birthright? Sounds as if Lab assumed this area would always vote Lab no matter how little the Party did for the people. Hope the voters think through the issues.
RM, poole, uk
"Desultory buses" ? Coming from Glasgow and now living in Berkshire I resent this description of Glasgow's public transport! At least in Glasgow you can get buses after 6.30p.m. and on a Sunday, impossible where I live now.
Rhona Winterburn, Reading, Berkshire
Phil in Dorset: The South East is prosperous in significant part because of Scottish oil. Scotland utterly rejected Thatcherism, but a different kind of conservatism might find a place in an independent Scotland. Annabel Goldie is held in affectionate regard by many on the left, but is a unionist.
Peter Curran, Kirkliston, Scotland
Paul, Coventry: Jim Sillars is nowhere, having left the SNP in a fit of pique. The Holyrood constituency of Govan is now held by he SNP, having won it last year. - the first time they won a Glasgow seat at a full election.
I think Glasgow East is too much of a stretch for the SNP, though.
Stuart, Glasgow,
I was a member of the labour party in this part of the east end during the eighties and left ,disillusioned. Melanie Reid is right when she says London Labour will not invest in a solid Labour seat , poverty ridden or not. SNP will. Labour kicked us so we should kick back. I'm for independence.
john fegan, glasgow, Scotland
Jim Sillars, Govan, 1988. Where is he now and what happened to the SNP on Rangers' home turf?
Paul, Coventry,
The SNP like Labour are very socialistic and big brother in
their thinking. The Scots need to consider voting Conservative,
why do you think that Southern-England is so prosperous?
The Scots are a brilliant inventive people who need to be set
free from the dead hand of the state.
Philip, Dorset, U.K.
Fine piece about my home parish.
Shame on you labour.
Phil Mac Giolla Bhain, letterkenny, ireland
A wonderful article. I am a Glasgow eastender by birth and upbringing. My support for Labour was unwavering throughout most of my life. But in May 2007, I voted for Alex Salmond and the SNP. The east end's only hope lies with the SNP. Labour have cynically betrayed eastenders for over half a century
Peter Curran, Kirkliston, Scotland
Ms Reid makes pertinent points about the crushing poverty evident in parts of the East End, but it is not different from any other working class area in any other large city in the UK. I found her tone condescending in the extreme and showed no insight into the character of the area!
andrew dougherty, Galsgow, UK
If we vote Celtic into power in Westminster and/ or Hollyrood this country would be the greatest on earth...just like the club!
P Flannery, Glasgow,
An outstanding article. Glasgow has levels of poverty that would NOT be tolerated in England. The drift to the SNP has partly been caused by the Conservatives and their media allies and their incredibly negative attitude to all things Scottish. Mr Cameron will cause the end of the UK plc
Thomas Campbell, Leicester, England
I was born and bred in Glasgow's East End. A lifelong Labour voter, I belatedly recognised the cynical betrayal of eastenders by Labour. I hope the resilient people of Shettleston throw out this moribund political party who have destroyed their dreams through three generations.
Thanks, Melanie Reid
Peter Curran, Kirkliston, Scotland
The Games are not about regeneration of the East End; more about regeneration immediately adjacent to Celtic Park, home of a company that a significant portion of Labour MSPs and Glasgow councillors have a shareholding in. Areas like Easterhouse will no benefit and may suffer as funding is diverted.
David, London,
Brilliant article. I knew Glasgow was a poor area but not that poor. Labour politicians do not live in the real world, Gordon Brown doesn't live in the real world, Glasgow is the harsh reality of the real world. I hope they lose again - in fact i hope every labour poltician loses their seat!
Alexander Grant, Hereford, England
Thanks Melanie, Great article. I'm a Glaswegian and just loved it.
Edward , Eugene,Oregon, USA
Excellent background article, Melanie, thank you. I knew very little about this seat before, and I will now enjoy Brown's nemesis more. Glasgow East looks pretty much like New Labour's story....lots of tax revenue invested, scant social improvement to show for it. Or so the slow bus declares!
Paul Freeman, London, England