Matthew Chalmers
Over 900 restaurants nationwide. Find your nearest now
The work that brought one US and two Japanese scientists this year's Nobel prize for physics won't mean much to most people. It concerns brilliant insights into the “broken” mathematical symmetries that govern the sub-atomic world, shedding light on why the universe contains any matter at all - which includes you and the air you breathe. It is precisely this kind of mind-blowing stuff that the £3.6 billion Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at CERN, currently down for repairs, was built to unearth by smashing particles together 600 million times per second inside a 27km subterranean fridge.
But you don't need a PhD in theoretical physics to appreciate one thing about this year's physics Nobel: it didn't go to the UK. In the ast three decades only one UK citizen has been awarded the Nobel Prize for physics: Tony Leggett in 2003. It's a conspicuous mismatch next to the 20 prizes accrued by UK physicists during the previous seven decades, and compares against six Nobels in chemistry and 11 in medicine picked up during the same period.
Meanwhile, Germany (population one third greater) has won ten, France (same population) four and the US (five times greater) a whopping 45 physics Nobels since 1978. Should we be concerned?
Nobel-calibre physics is world-changing. Last year's more widely reported prize went for the discovery of a magnetic effect that two decades later allows you to pack more DVDs on your hard drive. The 1964 prize recognised the invention of the laser that burns data on to those DVDs, and the microelectronics age itself was born with the transistor (1956 prize), around which electrons discovered by Cambridge physicist J. J.Thomson (1906 prize) are shunted.
Physics also underpinned the deciphering of DNA, bringing the UK physicist Francis Crick a share of the 1962 medicine Nobel. And the discovery of nuclear magnetic resonance (1952 physics Nobel), without which we would not have MRI scanners, has spawned further Nobels in chemistry and in medicine - the latter shared by UK physicist Sir Peter Mansfield, of Nottingham University, in 2003.
Science is no Olympic-like contest, but Nobel prizes bring national and institutional prestige, as well as a slice of ten million Swedish kroner. The Japanese Government is already capitalising on last week's announcement by hinting that it will use the “tailwind” of the Nobel to strengthen its case for hosting the LHC's multibillion-pound successor: a 40km long “international linear collider”, which could be operational in the 2020s. Given our politicians' worship of the knowledge economy, to which physics contributes some £70 billion annually, any signs that the UK's Nobel physics heritage is in decline should set government alarm bells ringing.
Yet the Nobel, awarded for a single discovery often decades after it was made, paints a rather different picture of UK physics than most other measures. The UK consistently punches above its weight in the number of citations its physics research papers receive, and excels in closely related disciplines such as earth science, mathematics and astronomy, which lie outside the Nobel remit. UK physicists also do well in other prizes such as the Wolf, often seen as a precursor to the Nobel.
Indeed, earlier this month the most extensive review of UK physics undertaken, chaired by Professor Bill Wakeham of Southampton University, concluded that the subject is in good health, although admitted that it faced big educational challenges (A-level entrants have plummeted by a third since 1993, the Institute of Physics estimates that we are up to 8,000 physics teachers short, and 20 university physics departments have closed since 1997).
Our recent dearth of physics Nobels could simply be a run of bad luck, and UK institutions may lack the resources to lure top names and be less inclined to lobby - factors which, on top of greater funding, may have helped to drive the huge rise in US physics Nobels over the past 50 years. What is unlikely to help matters, though, is the complete reliance of UK physics on central funding, compared with the booming biomedical sciences, for example, which benefit from support from the Wellcome Trust, charities and the pharmaceutical industry. Inevitably this limits the volume of basic physics research and generates a need for short-term societal and economic returns, none of which sits comfortably with the blue-skies, investigator-led research typical of Nobel recognition.
The Wakeham review is testament to this vulnerability. It was commissioned in response to an £80 million black hole which appeared in the quango that funds UK particle physics and astronomy late last year - something deemed by a Commons select committee to have damaged the UK's international standing in physics.
International reputations are vital in particle physics, which is far too expensive and complicated to be carried out by single countries. Whichever nation ends up hosting the international linear collider, it would reap scientific and economic rewards. Indeed, with an impeccable 54-year track record of European and international collaboration, CERN (which straddles the Swiss-French border just outside Geneva and to which the UK contributes £78 million annually) has its own plans for such a project.
The long-awaited LHC, which caught the world's attention when it switched on last month, should bring Nobel rewards. And if, as widely expected, it discovers a particle called the Higgs boson, a retired Englishman called Peter Higgs, of Edinburgh University, will almost certainly be on his way to Stockholm to boost our physics Nobel tally. That would give newspaper editors no excuse not to tell their readers about the broken mathematical symmetries of nature rewarded in the 2008 prize, since the Higgs boson is predicted to be the product of just that - explaining, no less, the origin of mass.
This year's Nobel prize for physics is one of tens that mark the enormous advances in our understanding of nature's fundamental constituents. It's a trail that leads right back to the quantum mechanics revolution at the beginning of the last century and to the UK, which helped to lay the foundations of modern physics and thus the modern world. The UK has an enormous scientific Nobel heritage. The club of living UK physics laureates has only three members. It's high time that number was increased.
Dr Matthew Chalmers is a writer and former particle physicist at CERN
The moment your toes touch the sand and your gaze meets water, you know you’re in the Bahamas
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2005 / 55
£59,500
Great car insurance deals online
Circa £60,000
The Army Benevolent Fund
London
£28k+ Basic + Commission
Drummond Selection
London
12-15 days a year, c £12K
Springboard
London
£Competitive
American Airlines
Heathrow, London
Great Investment, River Views
One and Two Bed Apartments
Wandsworth Town
Times Online Property Search will help you Find It
like nothing on Earth!
.
Must end 28 Feb 2009!
Save up to 25%
Amazing Far East Offers
Visit Malaysia from £755pp
Great travel insurance deals online
.
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Mark Henderson is doing all he can to ensure Higgs gets a Prize. Even though Higgs was last to the party.
Patrick, Chelsea, UK
Higgs has had a publicist for years - laughable that the article points out they don't promote themselves.
Patrick, Chelsea, UK
Higgs was last to the party and will not get it.
Patrick, Chelsea, UK
Systematic budget cuts plaguing UK science funding bodies produced a severe competition for grants and equipment. In my research area, UK remains famous for method development, but the truly cutting-edge applications that lead to industrial advances and Nobel-prize science are carried out elsewhere.
Andrew, , Japan
The US scientist who was awarded the 2008 prize in physics was also born in Japan. He moved to America and became naturalized there.
Best scientists may well deserve to choose the best work environment wherever in the world it is offered.
Tetsu, Tokyo, Japan
Comrades, be reasonable. Nobel prizes are rare events. We couldn't let small things like that get in the way of ensuring that everyone passes exams. Of course that meant lower standards, but not to worry, Following huge loans ot public money to banks, we are on course to win the cattle vote!
A.P. Paratchik, Erewhon,
Mike is right. I did a physics undergraduate degree at Imperial College a few years ago and most of my colleagues went straight into the city and I have retrained as a barrister. Very few stayed on to do PhDs. The reason? There is no money working in Physics, so clever people look elsewhere.
Alex, Brighton ,
Maybe they should work harder
Bhavik, Harrow, UK
As a former research scientist now working in the legal sector the lack of opporunity and rewards in science is disastrous. I did chase the money, but only because there was no way to raise a family on what I would have earned had I remained in research. A sad reflection on the UK's priorities.
Sean Harte, Dublin, Ireland
After completing my PhD in theoretical physics, I was faced with the prospect of pursuing post-doctoral research fellowships, which are poorly paid, short term (2 years typically) and involve frequent relocation, or getting a 'real' job.
I chose the latter (and ended up in the hedge fund industry).
Fred, Bristol, UK
Don't worry, we top of the league in media studies.
Dave, Stafford, UK
Easy, a direct cause, is the decline of grammar schools and a competitive education, where there is glory in being amongst the 'elite'!
David Vinter,, Louth, Lincs,, UK.
I agree totally with Chris. Let's start rewarding the brilliance, hard work and tenacity of our scientists not glorified spivs in the City.
P. Dodd, Darlington, UK
Since for a long time there's been too much investment money chasing too few promising companies, causing bubbles, why not use part of the eventual profits of our nationalised banks to fund pure scientific research? It could stabilise the economy&provide the basis for future profitable applications.
Chris, Harrow,
It's very simple - our brightest and best have been employed to produce ever more complex (and disasterous) financial instruments in the city of London. A society gets what it is willing to pay for.
Mike, Newport , Wales
I sincerely hope Mr Higgs is still around to receive the recognition he deserves, as Nobel prizes are often a long time coming,,,
Ben Griffiths, London,