Carl Mortished: World business briefing
Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000
With the bulk of British banking now perched uneasily on his shoulders, the Prime Minister is in Churchillian mode, calling for a new Bretton Woods agreement, harking back to the 1944 conference between the allied powers that led to the creation of the IMF, the World Bank and the guts of the global financial system.
Today, ominously, we have massive public intervention in the market, governments on the rampage against profiteering capitalism and the banishment of shareholder interest.
Is it Gordon Brown's finest hour? He has the jowels, the husky voice and the gruff manner (sadly, he lacks the oratory skill but that is a detail). The war analogies are coming thick and fast, so it is worth looking back and considering where we are in this financial crisis and where the Prime Minister might take us.
The Treasury's multibillion-pound gun batteries appear to have stopped the assault on the banks. There were even small signs of credit loosening yesterday as one-week dollar Libor, the rate at which banks believe that they can borrow US currency, fell by half a percentage point.
This is only one battle; after its “finest hour” in 1940, Britain continued to fight a debilitating war for five years. At the risk of stretching the war analogy to its limit, Mr Brown might reflect, in Churchill's words, that the rescue of the banks is not the end but, “perhaps, the end of the beginning”.
What lies ahead is a recession of unknown length and severity. The banks are not yet fully open for business; it will take time for them to restore even modest levels of lending.
After yesterday's market celebration, three-month sterling Libor was 6.25 per cent, compared with the Bank of England's base rate of 4.5 per cent. That suggests there won't be many cheap deals for homebuyers soon and small businesses will be paying double-digit rates for funds.
Such dear money will not finance a rapid economic recovery and it is the Government's fear that the financial crisis will subside into a lengthy slough of credit despond.
The Government wants banks to lend aggressively, hence the Treasury's injunction that the rescued will, for a period of three years, actively market loans to homeowners and small businesses at 2007 levels. The banks must “support schemes to help people struggling with mortgage payments to stay in their homes”.
There are several problems here. First, the “active marketing” of cheap loans is how we got into this mess; and secondly, the cost of supporting foolish borrowers must be borne by someone. Those who took out 110 per cent start-up mortgages two years ago will be suffering negative equity and higher rates now. If these people are to be kept in their homes, the banks must cross-subsidise them by charging more to solvent homeowners and sound businesses.
Finally, the Government is insisting that banks must serve Britain and do its bidding. There will be no dividends to ordinary shareholders. The preference coupon of 12 per cent on the government stakes in RBS, HBOS and Lloyds TSB precludes any cash payout for the private sector.
The Treasury and the banks protest the relationship will be at arm's length; the rescue will be for “a limited period”. If the markets continue to soar and Libor plummets over the next few weeks, the British taxpayer will enjoy a pleasant windfall.
More likely is a lengthy workout as the banks struggle to do business. The banks will shrink as they disband their exotic finance affiliates. Salaries will be unattractive and the best and brightest will flee to other industries.
These institutions will revert to old methods of doing business in order to fill the gap in business funding left by the collapse of the securitisation and derivative markets. Banks may become like the old discount houses, helping companies to secure short-term finance from the Bank of England by guaranteeing the trade debts of their customers.
If lending does not rebound, the Government will bear down even harder, intervening more openly at board level to direct investment. There will be government projects to fund - nuclear power plants, high-speed trains, runways and tunnels - and the banks will be encouraged to fund the national effort to help to “kickstart” the economy.
Within a year or two, RBS and Lloyds TSB/HBOS may have become quangos, semi-departments in a new Britain Inc led by a Prime Minister who once conducted economic policy by tinkering with the tax code - rewarding a bit here, punishing a bit there.
How much more satisfying not to have to tinker with silly tax incentives and how much more rewarding to set out an economic plan for the nation with compliant banks to fund it.
Absurd as it may sound, there is nothing strange about this - France nationalised Crédit Lyonnais in 1993 with the blessing of the European Commission, privatising it six years later.
Today the pressure to lead the economy from the prime ministerial bridge is more pressing. Even as we move into an era of rising unemployment, the Government wants to impose even greater costs on businesses and consumers in the fight against climate change. Greenhouse gas reductions of 20 per cent would be extremely challenging in a thriving economy.
Today, they look onerous, if not impossible. If these objectives are sincere, they can be achieved only in a command and control economy, where investment and rates of return are directed, not subject to market whim.
Those of us who were disgusted by the high-risk profiteering behaviour of juvenile bankers might find a disciplined, organised economy oddly attractive. Indeed, the British Government's strategy of muzzling the banks with high-coupon preference shares was replicated yesterday in Germany and in the United States.
But it will have ramifications for all of us. If the banks are not paying dividends, there will be a cost in our pensions, which have depended on the rapid growth in income from banking shares. That income cushion is gone and anyone approaching retirement is facing a less affluent old age.
carl.mortished@thetimes.co.uk
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
Special Offers now available
New Year in the USA!
.
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
You pay now or you pay later. It just depends where you want the pain.
As far as I can see, if they avoid the economy falling off a cliff now, it'll happen in 3-4 years from now. Move the second part of your pension from state control to a private plan and stick it index linked securities.
Jim, London, UK
Brown is in a catch 22. He would be criticised for doing nothing and yet the bail out will just prolong the agony- like Japan. Watching the UK economy is like watching the Titianic go down with the orchestra still playing.
B Cockell, Annecy, France
The deal will have to be renegotiated as in light of softer schemes in the rest of the world this puts UK banks at a huge disadvantage in a global market. Maybe labour are happy for another successful uk industry to be taken over by foreign companies and run for profits like the energy industry.
Stuz Graz, London, England
I detect the hand of Peter Mandelson masterminding this spin picked up by the media that 'Brown leads the world' with his 'bold rescue plan'. As you say, the closer you look at it, the more it tends to fall apart. Typical New Labour spin: that's why Mandelson was brought back: to spin the media.
Robert Cookson, Milton Keynes, UK
Your reference to greenhouse targets being more difficult to achieve in a recession I'm afraid shows ingorance - a recession means less consumption, less energy and therfore less CO2 - it will be easier!!
Ryan David, Cardiff, UK
STOP calling this growing depression a recession, I'm with William Kent and Kondratieff, this juggernaut has a good ten years and probably a major war before it changes course.
Roger, Airstrip 1,
The best and brightest will flee! I really cannot accept your judgment that the people who caused this crisis are the best and brightest! We need some good 17th century puritans for a change who have some moral fibre!
Brian Lewis, Manila, Philippines
james, Falkirk, UK
Get the facts right, BOE base rare is 4.5%, not 4%.....
Ewan , Sherborne, Dorset
I too am unable to comprehend the statement "actively market loans to homeowners and small businesses at 2007 levels". The banks must support schemes to help people struggling with mortgage payments to stay in their homes" surely that is what has got us into this mess in the first place.
Bob, London, UK
The length of the recession IS known.
It will be very long (think 10 years or more).
The severity of the recession IS known.
It will be very severe (think 1929 to 1939 to get an idea).
Cheers.
William Kent, Brandon, Canada
Experiences from my friends and I. Endowment mortgage scam, private pensions scam, occupational final salary pension destroyed by Brown. All done on the advice of "Independent Financial Advisers" So the game is to trust no one but yourself as advisers are either incompetent or liars in my view.
Rafael, Swindon, England
Pensions are being hit by the Short sellers, who are back again today, the market will be volatile again especially in the USA .When will they ban this practise and save our Pensions. When will the Press expose short selling as having no merit except for fatcats to earn millions from Pensioners
nigel, cobham, england
Carl - our elite are bubble addicts. The British economy has been puffed up by make believe money in the City. This inflated property and state income. The tirage has self-imploded like a ponzi. The inverted pyramid will shrink, hopefully, or collapse. We are going into an L shaped economy. I weep..
Simon, Harrogate, UK
In my life, I have worked with many competent bankers. I respected them. But it is true, this mess was created by 'juvenile bankers'. So I'd like to know how they got into that position. What organisational processes put them there?
Geoffrey, Sydney,
If high flying Bankers are so bright why are we in this mess?
B Calvert, London,
Dear Mark,
You, me and millions of others may well need a better state pension, unfortuneately, after bailing out the banks, paying for the extra unemployed and millions claiming other handouts, where will the money come from?
Labour showed it's contempt for pensioners 11 years ago.
Barry Samways, London, UK
Banks do not create wealth directly - the best they can do is invest money in businesses which are successful. So let us return to 'simple' banking where banks directly bear the risk of bad investments and cannot pass this on in cleverly disguised financial instruments. This will help stability.
Mark, Munich,
One day the UK population will wake up and discover that it has been badly shortchanged in pensions of late, not just relative to what used to happen here, but in comparison with most EU countries where the state plays a much larger and more stable role in pension provision. Our pensions are awful!
Colinc, shrewsbury,
Well its OK because we have all enjoyed 10 years of boom under the labour government. We were protected from an unregulated labour market, our borders were effectively secured and our tax was wisely used in order to protect us from rainy days.
God help us.
Graham, St. Albans, uk
Investors knew that the value of their pensions may go down as well as up. The people they entrusted with their pension money let them down by investing it in recklessly run companies, whose leadership they did not question, as shareholders. Tough luck. We'll just need better state pension provision
Mark, London, UK